The 5 Best Lash Glues, Tested and Reviewed

Our Testing Process

To start, we researched the top-rated eyelash glues on the market. After deep-diving into the ratings, we rounded up the 15 most popular options and put them to the test. Eight testers analyzed the lash glues on a scale of 1 to 5 in three important categories: Ease of application, hold/comfort, and wear. Once all the testers provided their feedback, we were able to weed out the so-so lash glues and narrow down the list to the 5 best glues.

What to Keep in Mind

Eyelid Sensitivity

The skin around the eyes is extremely sensitive and delicate. That being said, it’s important to treat that skin with the utmost care. Because products (including eyelash glue, eyelash serums, and eye creams) are formulated with a range of different ingredients, taking the ingredient list into account is vital. In terms of eyelash glue, look for formulas that are hypoallergenic or contain good-for-your-skin ingredients like vitamins A, C, or E (which the Ardell DUO Brush-On Lash Adhesive has). Additionally, if you are allergic to latex, stay away from formulas that include it. (Lily Lashes Clear Eyelash Glue has a latex-free formula). 

False Eyelashes

Eyelash glue and false lashes go hand-in-hand since you can’t (typically) have one without the other. Just as the type of glue is important, so are the lashes. Contrary to popular belief, not all glues will work with every lash type — this especially rings true when wearing thicker, heavy-duty eyelashes. If you tend to opt for heavier fringe, choose a super strong hold glue. Ardell DUO Brush-On Lash Adhesive is one of the best adhesives to use on more dramatic lashes because of its longevity and strength. 

Color

Typically when lash glue dries down it’s one of two colors: Clear or black. (Sometimes brown is also an option, but it’s not as common). We recommend sticking with a clear option (like PÜR Pro Eyelash Glue) if you’re looking for a more natural look or you’re a beginner because mistakes are unrecognizable and can be covered up. Black glue, on the other hand, leaves a lot of room for error. It’s best to use black glue if you’re going for a dramatic look and wearing thick eyeliner, as the hue will blend into the eyeliner. Sephora Brush-Tip Lash Adhesive has the richest black glue with optimal staying power, making it one of our favorite colored options. 

Your Questions, Answered

How do you use lash glue?

It’s important to know how to properly apply lash glue to avoid irritating or damaging the delicate skin around the eyes. “No matter which type of lash glue you pick — eyeliner style or the one that comes in a tube — always apply it onto your falsies and not on your lid,” says beauty expert and founder of the Style Sprinter blog, Katya Bychkova. “The only exception to this rule is magnetic lash glue, [which is] designed to be used directly on your lid, just like an eyeliner.” From there, be sure you wait about 15 seconds before applying the lash to your lid. This will ensure the consistency is not too runny. “If you don't allow your lash glue to become gooey before applying it to your lid, it will be less likely to stick and might move your eye makeup,” she explains.

How do you remove lash glue from lashes?

“There are a few options for removing lash glue from lashes: An oil-based makeup remover, a dedicated lash cleansing solution, or just physically removeing glue with cotton swabs,” explains Bychkova. “The first two options are the safest for your falsies, as physical removal might bend the lash permanently.” To remove the glue, dampen a cotton pad with an oil-based makeup remover or lash cleansing solution and gently rub lashes until the glue is gone.

How do you remove lash glue from eyelids?

If you have leftover lash glue stuck to eyelids, there are a few ways to safely remove it. “Don’t panic,” says lash expert and founder of Urban Doll, Sima Mosbacher. “If you don’t have makeup on your eyes already, simply wait for the glue to dry and use a tweezer or Q-Tip to swipe off — similar to the way some remove mascara.”

How long does lash glue last?

Like most beauty products, lash glue has an expiration date indicated on the package. “In my own experience, lash glues last around six months after you buy it,” says Mosbacher. “To keep it in top shape, make sure you fully close the tube after using it to avoid the product from drying out.” Additionally, celebrity makeup artist Andrew Velázquez notes that if the glue is too thick or sticky, throw it away.

What is InStyle Picks?

Did you notice the InStyle Picks seal of approval at the top of this story? That means our team of testers has reviewed every product on this list using a unique methodology to ensure it's really worth your time, money, and attention. We may get samples for free to try but we never promise positive (or any!) coverage in exchange. Put simply: InStyle picks are products we love, and we've put them to the test to be sure you will too.

Why Trust InStyle

Lauren Harano has been contributing to InStyle since August 2022, where she covers skincare, makeup, and hair care. She is knowledgeable about all things beauty and has tested hundreds of products during her career. For this article, Lauren interviewed three beauty experts: celebrity makeup artist Andrew Velázquez; founder of the Style Sprinter blog, Katya Bychkova; and lash expert and founder of Urban Doll, Sima Mosbacher. All three experts lent their expertise and shared what they find important in lash glues. Additionally, Lauren compiled insights from our in-house testers, poured over product specifications, and rounded up our top picks for this story. Each eyelash glue on this list is effective, safe for sensitive skin, and works well with all lash types.